Badian District Hospital probed over alleged emergency care delay
LAPU-LAPU CITY, Cebu — Cebu health officials have begun investigating the alleged delay in emergency care provided to a patient at Badian District Hospital after a motorcycle crash on Sunday, July 26, 2026.
The probe followed claims from the patient’s family that limited emergency care and facilities, coupled with difficulties in securing a hospital transfer, contributed to his death after a traumatic brain injury.
Family’s complaint
In a Facebook post dated Wednesday, July 29, the patient’s sibling, Jerryel Velvestre, recounted the family’s experience at Badian District Hospital.
Velvestre said that when the family arrived at the hospital, they found the patient struggling without medical assistance. They were told that personnel had given him paracetamol.
“My brother was obviously in pain, fighting for his life and in dire help of urgent care,” Velvestre said in the post.
The post also said the referral process was delayed. Hospital staff reportedly informed the family that the facility had lost internet connectivity.
Patient’s arrival at Badian Hospital
Velvestre further described hospital personnel as lacking urgency and sensitivity in attending to the patient and communicating with the family.
READ: PHO probes Carcar prov’l hospital over death of infant
“Daan nami galagot og pag ayo kay dili normal sa naay emergency ang ilang linihokan didto (We were already angry because it wasn’t how an emergency should be handled),” Velvestre said.
After learning about the family’s public complaint, Dr. Jenina Canoy, Provincial Health Officer (PHO), said they gathered incident reports from hospital personnel who attended to the patient.
The PHO’s initial review found that the young male patient arrived at Badian District Hospital through local emergency services at 4 a.m.
Transfer to another hospital recommended
Emergency records described the patient as being in “poor condition” upon arrival, with initial assessments indicating a traumatic brain injury.
READ: Bantayan hospital now offers surgical procedures
Reports also showed that personnel administered an intravenous (IV) drip and oxygen support, along with paracetamol and mannitol.
Canoy said that doctors then decided to transfer the patient to a tertiary hospital for a complete assessment and further management.
Badian District Hospital is a primary health facility, meaning it does not provide the specialized services available at tertiary hospitals.
From one hospital to another
At 4:40 a.m., hospital personnel began making online referrals to Vicente Sotto Memorial Medical Center (VSMMC) and Cebu Provincial Hospital (CPH)-Carcar.
Records from the electronic referral portal showed that CPH-Carcar declined the patient at 5 a.m. and recommended transfer to a tertiary-level facility.
The patient was referred to Cebu South Medical Center. It also declined to accept the patient because it had no ward vacancy.
Between 5 and 7 a.m., hospital personnel called the 711 hotline to ask whether the patient could be transported to VSMMC without formal acceptance.
In need of a neurosurgeon
However, this was discouraged because of the patient’s unstable condition.
“With tertiary facilities, they will instruct us to transport only when the patient is stable,” Canoy said in a mix of Cebuano and English.
Capitol Piso Health Consultant Dr. Elisse Nicole Catalan said that VSMMC was the most equipped facility to handle the patient. It had a neurosurgeon capable of treating the traumatic brain injury.
The family arrived at 7 a.m. and received updates about the patient’s condition and the status of the referrals.
About an hour later, hospital personnel sent referrals to two private hospitals preferred by the family.
Loss of connectivity
Canoy said that the referral process continued despite the reported internet outage. Personnel used other service providers and mobile data.
Amid “rising tension,” hospital personnel proceeded with transporting the patient to VSMMC. The facility had not yet formally accepted the referral.
Canoy said that while the ambulance was en route, VSMMC accepted the referral at 8:30 a.m.
The patient remained in critical condition throughout the journey, the records showed.
While on the way to VSMMC, the family decided to bring the patient to a private hospital without a referral.
Corrective measures
The patient arrived and was accepted at the private facility at 11 a.m. He died at 4:50 p.m. on the same day.
As complaints about public healthcare facilities pour online, Catalan said that the provincial government is seeking partnerships with trauma specialists. This will help strengthen emergency care and improve the management of similar cases.
Dr. Catalan added that discussions are underway to provide training to improve how patients and their families are assisted in hospitals.
The provincial government will also implement stricter measures against underage drinking, driving under the influence, and failure to wear helmets. They will do this in coordination with the Philippine National Police.
Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of Cebudailynews. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.