Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.

An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.

THE COURT OF Appeal has upheld a former Defence Force member’s conviction for the repeated rape of a fellow soldier, rejecting his argument that the jury shouldn’t have heard the victim’s distressed 999 call.

Kielan Mooney (30) of Bloomfield Park, Derry, was convicted following a trial at the Central Criminal Court in December 2024 of anal rape, oral rape and rape of the woman at a Dublin hotel on 26 July 2021.

He was jailed for eight and a half years by Mr Justice Tony Hunt in January the following year.

Mooney had pleaded not guilty to a total of six charges – two charges of rape, two charges of oral rape, a charge of anal rape and a charge of sexual assault. The jury failed to reach a verdict on the three remaining charges.

The victim, who is in her 20s, is also a serving soldier of the Irish Defence Forces. She indicated that while she was content for Mooney to be named in reporting of the case, she did not wish to be identified.

Mooney appealed his conviction, arguing that a recording of a 999 call made by the complainant after the incident should not have been admitted at trial.

His senior counsel Dominic McGinn said that by the time the call was made at 1.38am, the appellant had left the scene, the complainant’s friend had arrived, and she had spoken to her mother on the phone approximately half an hour earlier.

He said there had been “an abundance of evidence” of the complainant’s emotional state, so the phone call was not necessary to illustrate this. He said the victim told the call handler, whilst in a distressed state, that she had been raped.

McGinn the prejudicial nature of the evidence outweighed its probative value.

Counsel argued that this created “a real injustice” in the case and allowed the jury to draw conclusions that were not permissible and the judge erred in admitting it.

However, Patrick Gageby SC, for the State, said it was a paradox to suggest that because there was distress in the case and that wasn’t in issue, that the 999 call was somehow inadmissible.

He said the issue of rape arose because the operator asked the complainant what had happened. He said the defence case was that the victim was distressed not because she had been raped, but because she was “disappointed” that the appellant had left and she didn’t want him to.

In dismissing the appeal on Tuesday, presiding judge Ms Justice Tara Burns said the court did not agree with the appellant’s case that there was little probative value with respect to what was played on the call.

“The reality is the issue of her distress was a matter before the jury,” she said. “While her being distressed wasn’t at issue, the reason for her distress was.”

Ms Justice Burns, who sat with Mr Justice John Edwards and Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy, noted Mooney had asserted during the course of the trial that the reason for the victim’s distress was because he was leaving.

“It clearly was of relevance, and it clearly was at issue in terms of the jury’s determination,” said the judge.

She said this was “relevant, probative” material that was properly referred to the jury and was admissible before them.

Ms Justice Burns said its probative value outweighed its prejudicial effect and the court was dismissing the appeal.

The trial heard the woman was out socialising with other army members when they met a group of soldiers from Mooney’s barracks in Donegal.

She and Mooney got speaking and they decided to go back to the woman’s friend’s hotel room in the city centre.

The woman told the trial that Mooney anally raped her in her friend’s hotel room. She said she had asked him to stop but he did not.

Afterwards she went to the bathroom and was crying. She managed to text her friend. Mooney came into the room and asked her what was wrong before he took her by the hand and brought her back into the bedroom.

Mooney then forced the woman to perform oral sex on him before he pushed her on to the bed and raped her.

The woman managed to get back into the bathroom and phoned her friend who told her that she and two other male friends were nearly at the hotel. After they arrived, the two men forced Mooney out of the room and the gardaí were called.

To embed this post, copy the code below on your site